NDA: We Disclose All
October 7, 2008 at 8:02 am | In Study hints | Leave a CommentTags: NDA
A while back in Trika’s post about Microsoft’s anti-test-piracy meeting, someone asked how the NDA applies to study guides and test prep providers. Because many (if not the majority of) certified IT professionals are genuinely worried about certification fraud, this person was concerned about the similarities between some vendors’ test prep materials and live exam questions, including our own.
As we write the practice exam, we have two main goals (well, two besides accuracy, because that’s always first. And, after I’m involved, rigorously correct punctuation. But besides those):
- Does our exam cover all the vendor’s content from the test preparation guide?
- Does our exam represent the format in which the vendor asks the questions?
I believe the second part is where people can become confused. Because we focus on preparing you for the entire exam experience, our practice test items can look a lot like “the real thing,” because we don’t want you figuring out how to work, say, a drag-and-drop on your first live exam; we want you focused on the content. So rest assured that while our tests might “look” real, they disclose no live exam questions (or, in Douglas Adams terms, they produce a beverage which is almost, but not quite, entirely unlike tea).
As a followup to Robin’s post, I put together a comprehensive list of the common certification vendors, their general exam and certification policies, and their individual non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), where available. In many cases, the vendor also outlines the penalties for certification fraud, and answers explicit questions about what may or may not constitute “violating” the NDA.
Big List O’ Vendor NDAs and exam policies
Cisco Certification Exam Policies
http://www.cisco.com/web/learning/le3/le11/learning_certification_exam_policies.html
Click here to see the rest of the list of vendor NDAs and exam policies.
“Just what the heck is that legal document I have to sign to take a test?”
October 6, 2008 at 9:41 am | In Study hints | 1 CommentTags: braindumps, fraud, NDA
I recently received a rather disgruntled e-mail from a customer, stating that he didn’t see a single item from our practice test on the live exam. My initial reaction was happiness – we work hard to not violate the vendor Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) when we assemble our tests. It was quickly followed by concern over the customer’s expectations. After e-mailing back and forth with the customer, explaining the theory behind our tutorials, he began studying the tutorials in depth instead of passing them over after answering a question correctly. He said later he was surprised at the amount of useful information they contianed. (For more information on why this technique works, see the blog post entitled The Secret Path to Knowledge and a Better Exam Experience.)
Thinking back on this exchange, I realize that many certification candidates may have unrealistic expectations of a legitimate practice test vendor. Our job is to prepare you for the content you will see on the test. But we straddle a fine line – one between serving our customers’ needs, and ensuring that we do not violate the NDA. You should never expect to see the exact same questions on a practice test and a live exam. This is a direct violation of the NDA.
But you may wonder just what an NDA is. An NDA is that little agreement you “sign” just before your live exam starts. If you’ve taken a certification exam, it’s that screen that looks like a legal document that you probably do not take the time to read, but it is very binding. By clicking the I Agree button, you are saying that you will not violate the policy in any manner. While NDAs across vendors vary, they all include guidelines about NOT sharing test content with the public that includes removing notes, taking pictures, and so on. Punishment for violation of the NDA varies, but it can lead to losing all of your current and future IT certifications.
Now all of us have seen or heard of braindump sites (or companies that call themselves practice test vendors) that claim that you can memorize their test questions and answers and pass the test easily. You probably even know someone who has used them (but of course, have never used them yourself).
Nothing frustrates me more than to have someone compare Transcender’s products to these sites. They have nothing to do with legitimate test preparation. These sites directly violate the NDA; some of these sites have even been prosecuted by certification vendors. Their products generally are just the questions, options, and (someone’s opinion of) the correct answer. (Some of these braindump tests have passed over my desk, and let me tell you, the companies just care about making a buck; they don’t care about accuracy. I have often seen the wrong answer marked as “correct.” But how are you going to complain after you’ve used their product to cheat on a test?) They usually do not include tutorials or references. They don’t tell you the why or how of an item. They are just a way to cheat and cheapen the value of the IT certification.
This is such a big topic that it can’t possibly be addressed in one post, but we have a series of articles planned about what IT certification fraud is, its impact, and the countermeasures that vendors are taking (including targeting the consumer – that’s you!).
Until next time
-Robin
Blog at WordPress.com. | Theme: Pool by Borja Fernandez.
Entries and comments feeds.